TP 003
The Nature of Wholeness
Can different forms exist as one? Circles added one by one close in on an octagon, but its corners exist only in the limit.
Field
Detail
Study
TP 003
Chapter
Quantum mechanics
Equation
z(t) = Σ e^(int)/n², n ≡ 1 (mod 8)
What moves
k, the number of terms; the camera, round Ganesha and in to one vertex of the octagon; the rosette network, ring by ring
Structure
Film
Colour means
blue, Ganesha's body and the partial sums S_k; violet, the halo, the first circle and the rings; indigo, the crown, jewellery and pedestal; magenta, the eight primary rosettes; cyan, the smallest rosettes; white, the limit P
Posted

One question runs through this profile: can different forms exist as one? Ganesha has long been depicted with an elephant's head and a human body, as one being. The stories of how he came by the elephant's head differ from text to text; the film does not retell them. The figure is there from the first frame, already one.
One circle. A point moves round a circle at a steady speed: z(t) = e^(it). This is the first part.
More circles are added, one at a time. Their frequencies are 1, −7, 9, −15, 17 and so on: every whole number n with n ≡ 1 (mod 8), a negative frequency turning the other way. Each circle's size is 1/n². From the very first term, every sum has the same eightfold symmetry. Some order holds at every step.
Closer with every term. The sums S₅, S₁₀, S₂₀ draw ever closer to a regular octagon. With 5 terms the curve is within 1.2 % of it; with 200 terms, within 0.03 %.
Yet every finite sum is smooth. However many terms are added, the curve has no corner: it only bends more sharply near the vertices. The corner exists only in the limit, the octagon itself, which the film draws from its definition, eight straight edges, not by adding infinitely many terms.
Behind the figure, a network of eightfold rosettes grows ring by ring, and the figure and the geometry stand in one frame.
What follows is a reading, not a mathematical fact. A whole can arise from many parts, and some of what defines it is of two kinds: order kept at every stage, and properties that appear only in the limit. The octagon does not go beyond its parts; it is their limit. Ganesha's form and the octagon are not the same kind of whole: one belongs to tradition and meaning, the other to mathematics.
Where physics comes in. In quantum mechanics, the state of two entangled systems sometimes cannot be written as a combination of the states of its parts. Whether a whole is more than its parts is asked there too, with experiments and mathematics. It is a question of the same shape, not the same claim. Ganesha's image did not anticipate quantum mechanics.
The question stays open: can different forms exist as one?
Ganesha form based on "Lord Ganesha Hindu Deity 04 Brass Statue" by Vijay Saini (Sketchfab), CC BY 4.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0). Modified by Mokujiro Studio: rescaled, back surface smoothed, rendered as wireframe.