TP 001

Who Was Nāgārjuna?

Does anything exist on its own? Nāgārjuna looked for a nature that depends on nothing and found none. Empty does not mean nothing.

Field

Detail

Study

TP 001

Chapter

Quantum mechanics

Equation

MMK 24.18

What moves

the camera, round Nāgārjuna and in among the forms; the links between the forms, one at a time; the network, as the camera pulls back

Structure

Film

Colour means

blue, Nāgārjuna and the forms; violet, the nāga and the forms around them; blue violet, the relations between them

Cover still of the study

One question runs through this profile: does anything exist on its own? Nāgārjuna asked it of things, of people, of minds and of time.

Who he was. He probably lived in southern India, around 150 to 250 CE. Beyond that, little is certain. Later tradition says he brought scriptures back from the undersea palace of the nāgas, the serpent beings of Indian myth; that is legend, not history. The work handed down as his is the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, the Middle Way Verses.

Where he started. Centuries before him, the Buddha taught a middle way: neither "everything exists" nor "nothing exists" (SN 12.15, one of the early discourses). Nāgārjuna cites that teaching by name (MMK 15.7: the Middle Way Verses, chapter 15, verse 7), then goes a step further and tests it by argument. The Buddha's middle way and Madhyamaka, the school that grew from Nāgārjuna's arguments, are connected, but they are not the same thing.

What he looked for. He called it svabhāva: a nature that is not made and depends on nothing else (MMK 15.2). He examined arising, motion, time and the self, one by one, and found nothing like it.

What he concluded. "What arises in dependence, we call emptiness" (MMK 24.18, our translation from the Sanskrit). To arise in dependence is to come about only through causes and conditions. Think of a rainbow. It appears only when sunlight, drops of water in the air and someone standing in the right place come together. Take one away and it is gone. The rainbow is really there, but it does not stand on its own. Empty does not mean nothing. Nor is emptiness itself an independent thing. The analogy has a limit: in a rainbow, the sun and the drops seem to stand on their own. For Nāgārjuna they do not, and neither do the relations between them.

Where physics comes in. Eighteen centuries later, the physicist Carlo Rovelli read Nāgārjuna while thinking about relational quantum mechanics, the view that a system's properties are defined only relative to other systems. He wrote about him in Helgoland (2020), and in a 2025 interview said that Nāgārjuna voices a very similar idea: nothing has an independent existence of its own.

The difference. One is physics: how to read quantum theory, checked against experiment. The other is philosophy: whether anything has svabhāva, checked by argument. Their objects, methods and aims differ, and for Nāgārjuna the relations are empty too. So this is a comparison, not an equivalence. Nāgārjuna did not anticipate quantum mechanics, and quantum mechanics has not proved him right.

Different fields, the same question. Study CS 010 compares the two directly.

← Previous

BO 001

The Observer

Next →

065

Stern-Gerlach

Each study takes one equation and lets the computed result move.